Comfyui vs a1111 The a1111 ui is actually doing something like (but across all the tokens): I usually get around 1. To use it, you must update ComfyUI, which you can do easily with ComfyUI Manager. Thus, even if you use the same setting you will either get an image that is the same or closely similar like in this case. Aug 6, 2024 · a1111からEasySdxlWebUiを活用してforgeを使っています。 さらにComfyUIでもAI画像生成をしています。 その中でforgeとComyUIを同じcheckPointとプロンプトで実施した所、画像の違いがあったので、そちらを比較してみました。 Generating noise on the GPU vs CPU does not affect performance in any way. Tested failed loras with a1111 they were great. This is where A1111 shines. Two new ComfyUI nodes: CLIPTextEncodeA1111: A variant of CLIPTextEncode that converts A1111-like prompt into standard prompt I had previously used ComfyUI with SDXL 0. Feb 3, 2024 · They also mostly assume you are migrating from a1111 to ComfyUI, and already have models downloaded. Also Replicate increased their pricing so I’ve… Comfyui with python 3. Reply reply More replies Top 1% Rank by size Automatic1111 is great, but the one that impressed me, in doing things that Automatic1111 can't, is ComfyUI. I have 1060 with 6gb ram. If I'm asked to give an example of an interface that is as unfriendly to the user as possible, this plugin will be the first thing that comes to my mind. Esto se debe principalmente a dos factores clave: el método de generación de ruido y el manejo de pesos de los prompts. Noise on ComfyUI is generated on the CPU while the a1111 UI generates it on the GPU. I haven't found easy methods to replicate stuff like that in Compare ComfyUI vs a1111-nevysha-comfy-ui and see what are their differences. It seems upscale with model only works with image not latent. it's the perfect tool to explore generative ai. 5000 calls vs 3500 calls. Foocus [1] also seems to be popular and a bit more conventional perhaps, though I didn't try it. Just install it from the extensions tab, right click > Edit your webui-user. 3. I really would prefer Comfy as A1111 frequently enters "ultra slow" mode, where it takes minutes to generate vs seconds, then I need to restart A1111 to fix. 0 A1111 vs ComfyUI 6gb vram, thoughts Aug 2, 2024 · 新版のForge：v1. 「AUTOMATIC1111」ユーザー向けに「ComfyUI」のインストールから基本的な使い方について解説しています。Stable Diffusionをさらに自分流に使いこなして画像生成を楽しみましょう。 I have comfyui installed on my computer with a lot of custom nodes, Loras, controlnets I would like to have automatic1111 also installed to be able to use it. I'm unsure if setting A1111 Emphasis mode (in Settings - Stable Diffusion) to 'No Norm' will fix this, but seems worth a try. bat file and put in --api where it says COMMANDLINE_ARGS= ¿Por qué ComfyUI y A1111 Generan Imágenes Diferentes con la Misma Semilla? Cuando usas ComfyUI y Automatic1111 WebUI (A1111), podrías notar que incluso con el mismo valor de semilla, las imágenes generadas son diferentes. On my 12GB 3060, A1111 can't generate a single SDXL 1024x1024 image without using RAM for VRAM at some point near the end of generation, even with --medvram set. Personally I mainly use Forge, but what experience I do have with ComfyUI I'd say that the former is way easier to just change things around and experiment with, while the latter would absolutely excel in making something in a more repeated fashion. I tried --lovram --no-half-vae but it was the same problem Nov 7, 2023 · You probably applied prompt weighting same as A1111. 5 입니다. May 12, 2025 · Why Do ComfyUI and A1111 Generate Different Images with the Same Seed? When using ComfyUI and Automatic1111 WebUI (A1111), you might notice that even with the same seed value, the generated images differ. This means you do need a greater understanding of how Stable Diffusion works, but once you have that, it becomes more powerful than A1111 without having to resort to code. A1111 is more like a sturdy but highly adaptable workbench for image generation. Source. When convert to ComfyUI, you should lower the weighting. Add the PerturbedAtttentionGuidance node between the Model and KSampler node. This workflow is a brief mimic of A1111 T2I workflow for new comfy users (former A1111 users) who miss options such as Hiresfix and ADetailer. " The We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Nov 26, 2023 · Automatic1111からComfyUIへの移行で手間取った点を備忘録として残します。少しずつ移行して行く予定なのでその都度更新します。 ComfyUIのダウンロードや基本的なGUIの説明は以下サイトが参考になります。 【Stable Diffusion】ComfyUIとは？インストール方法と基本的な使い方について | イクログ (ikuriblog May 12, 2025 · 解决ComfyUI Manager安全级别报错「This action is not allowed」的完整指南; 如何在局域网中访问 ComfyUI; 如何在 ComfyUI 中调整字体大小：分步指南; 如何更改 ComfyUI 的输出文件夹位置; 如何启用 ComfyUI 新版本菜单; 为什么使用相同的种子值，ComfyUI 和 A1111 生成的图像不一样？ Aug 31, 2024 · つまり、従来の「AUTOMATIC1111」だけでなく「ComfyUI」に関する注目が相対的に3倍に増えているということで、AUTOMATIC1111（以下A1111）からComfyUIに全移行しているということではなく、興味関心が集まっており、かつこの分野「画像生成AI」の検索人口が増えて Aug 1, 2023 · 但是，实际上并不是这样的。经过更严谨的测试后发现，A1111和Comfyui只在75个字符前的出图大致一致，超过了75个字符后，相同的提示词在两者中可能也会出现不一样的结果，比如下图： Aug 29, 2023 · Configuring Models Location for ComfyUI. The script comfyui_a1111_prompt_array_generator. As far as I can tell, how prompt weighting is handled is one of the key differences between ComfyUI and A1111 (A1111 does some kind of normalization I think). I really like the extensions library and ecosystem that already exists around A1111- in particular stuff like 'OneButtonPrompt' which is great for inspiration on styles, etc. Hand Fix (MeshGraphormer) Stable Diffusion UI guide - A1111, Fooocus, ComfyUI, Invoke, Kohya by Sebastian Kamph inside ThinkDiffusion ↓Getting started with Stable Diffusion by ThinkDi Apr 15, 2023 · With the latest update to ComfyUI it is now possible to use the AdvancedClipEncode node which gives you control over how you want prompt weights interpreted and normalized. ComfyUI ComfyUI example node-based workflow view. Desperately waiting for a massive patch in A1111 to account for a trillion bugs that no fresh install would fix, and also memory management, models management, etc. sd-webui-comfyui is an extension for A1111 webui that embeds ComfyUI workflows in different sections of the normal pipeline of the webui. With ComfyUI you just download the portable zip file, unzip it and get ComfyUI running instantly, even a kid can get ComfyUI installed. I cant think if anything comfyui can do that I cant do in automatic1111. Face restoration (A1111): off No Hires. While it’s not perfect, it’s more stable than A1111/Forge. ComfyUI The most powerful and modular diffusion model GUI, api and backend with a graph/nodes interface. and nothing gets close to comfyui here. ComfyUI vs Automatic1111 (A1111) ComfyUI and Automatic1111 (sometimes also called A1111 or stable-diffusion-webui) are the two most popular Stable Diffusion UIs, and they both have their strengths and weaknesses. Never liked anything to do with nodes. I think the noise is also generated differently where A1111 uses GPU by default and ComfyUI uses CPU by default, which makes using the same seed give different results. It offers more control over the image generation process than Automatic1111, making it a better choice for advanced users who want to fine-tune the model parameters and create complex workflows. Here's the thing, ComfyUI is very intimidating at first so I completely understand why people are put off by it. It has now taken upwards of 10 minutes to do seemingly the same run. Nov 11, 2024 · Stable Diffusion WebUI Forge/reForge 都是将A1111 WebUI的整体效能优化提升而不改变原WebUI操作界面，用户无需重新学习适应。 建议A1111 WebUI用户使用。 reForge 是 Forge 的后辈，但两者有相同的血缘，reForge在后端、调度和功能上优化加强了一些。 May 3, 2023 · For runtime, I use ComfyUi [0] which is node based and therefore a bit hard to learn. I am still unsure what controlNet is for but I see multiple vid2vids on YT using it with other stuff and just curious if anyone can fill me in on Feb 2, 2025 · Images will have a1111 metadata embedded so you can upload them to Civitai with proper prompt and resources recognition. A1111 expected me know what a VAE was without giving me any context. For example you can make colors more vivid with saturation, remove yellow tint of some artists with temperature etc. This makes ComfyUI seeds reproducible across different hardware configurations but makes them different from the ones used by the a1111 UI. In ComfyUI using Juggernaut XL, it would usually take 30 seconds to a minute to run a batch of 4 images. A1111 calls more aten::linear than Forge. Added easy negative - simple My workflow is select part of my image in Photoshop (often with mask), paste into A1111, inpaint, paste back into Photoshop as another layer, then blend as needed. From 9it/s to 22it/s and with less VRAM used I think. My main use of Stable Diffusion is to generate complex scenes with multiple characters or objects. 9 if Aug 16, 2023 · 精度も速度もComfyUIの方が上に感じますね。 すべて一回しか検証をしていないのは、何度やってもかかる時間がほとんど変わらないからです。 ただし、Stable Diffusion web uiだけは起動後の一回目の生成は少し時間がかかるので、これは例外としています。 Jul 29, 2023 · 说起 AUTOMATIC1111 的 Stable diffusion-wbui 这个项目，使用过Stable diffusion的人应该无人不知吧，网络上基本一边倒的在使用他家的项目，而且fork量和star量还不小： 但是 AUTOMATIC1111 这个名字总给我一些… May 12, 2025 · 目前 ComfyUI 官方已推出 ComfyUI Desktop 版本，可以像普通软件程序一样安装，可以方便的进行安装，如果你是 Windows 用户，强烈建议你使用 ComfyUI Desktop 版本. If you are a Windows user, we strongly recommend using the ComfyUI Desktop version. Comfy feels more streamlined and flexible. Do they always produce the same image? The answer is no. I'll probably stick to ComfyUI from here on out, unless A1111 gets some crazy feature that ComfyUI doesn't have. I was tested on A1111 and comfyui to produce similar image before. Its like an experimentation superlab. SDXL configs I saw where either a mess or really confusing. It also has som I was trying to get Comfyui to produce similar result to hires fix using RealESRGAN_x4plus_anime_6B, it gives me desired effect for anime style images. I used A1111 for a long time, but when I started using ComfyUI - I can't really go back at this point, it feels too "stuffy" there. Noise Generation Differences ComfyUI’s Approach That being said, some users moving from a1111 to Comfy are presented with a brick wall rather than a steep learning curve. Its user-friendly interface, robust performance, and comprehensive documentation make it a pleasure to use. ComfyUI Desktop Installation Guide; ComfyUI Desktop version now natively supports English, Chinese, Russian, Japanese, and Korean AUTOMATIC1111 Stable Diffusion Web UI (SD WebUI, A1111, or Automatic1111 [3]) is an open source generative artificial intelligence program that allows users to generate images from a text prompt. 3) (quality:1. I want to switch from a1111 to comfyui. yaml after launching ComfyUI Desktop, under the menu Help -> Open Folder -> Open extra_model_paths. A1111 will always be slower than Comfy, that’s not up for debate since Comfy was designed to be a light weight implementation of SD, but it’s not slower by a huge amount. fix, no refiner, no ADetailer, Environment Hardware: i5-4440, 32 GB DDR3 RAM, NVidia 3060 with 12GB VRAM (on a mainboard with PCIe 3) Software: Linux (Debian 12), A1111 on version 1. This is primarily due to two key factors: noise generation method and prompt weight handling. A1111 also has easy to install extensions, including openoutpaint which gives you a canvas to out / inpaint on like Invoke does. A1111 tends to have a very weak effect of prompts compared to ComfyUI, so you must have given strong weighting to match it. Since the backend is ComfyUI, everything runs fast and efficiently. Running SDXL they are pretty similar speeds on my 4090, Comfy is maybe 10-15% faster without having measured precisely. if I need a few ideas. On the other hand inpainting and sketch is awfully slow in Forge. Besides better resource management, I really don't like it. It can be combined with existing checkpoints and the Jul 31, 2023 · Some interest findings of A1111 and comfyui. 9000calls vs 1900 calls. The guides that are out there for ComfyUI are either cryptic or hard to follow. It says something like this "prompt executed in xx seconds". 2) and just gives weird results. ComfyUI Desktop 版本安装教程; ComfyUI Desktop 版本现在原生支持英文、中文、俄语、日语、韩语; 有诸多体验优化 If I remember correctly, this is because in A1111 the latent noise space is generated in the GPU whereas in ComfyUI it is generated in the CPU instead. 11 will use the least amount of memory in my experience. 5's training time (~675 vs. 5のi2iにおいてTiled DiffusionとControlNet Tileを併用した顔の書き込みに関してです。 どう Forge UI is up to 75% faster than A1111 and ComfyUI. Please check it out! https://github. Reduce gamma to 0. Also, it's not about the time only, look how much resources uses one and the other for complete the same task. Thank you so much for reading 💖 Like | Follow | Subscribe to the newsletter. Its image compostion capabilities allow you to assign different prompts and weights, even using different models, to specific areas of an image. Never said A1111 had good UX/UI, I just said it's a lot more intuitive than ComfyUI. If using fp8 is the only way to not fall into ram usage or out of memory errors go with it, but if you can manage to avoid it, know that using fp8 in non 40xx cards is a bit slower. Dec 10, 2024 · Whether you choose A1111 or ComfyUI, both tools are powerful allies in the quest for stunning AI-generated imagery. There are more detailed instructions in the ComfyUI README. Apr 17, 2023 · Run Flux model (gguf) with LoRA in ComfyUI Recently I’m generating images using Flux’s hosted version, but its been quite expensive. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. yaml file within the ComfyUI directory. Thank you so much, that did help a great deal. and don't get scared by the noodle forests you see on some screenshots. Yeah. This allows to create ComfyUI nodes that interact directly with some parts of the webui's normal pipeline. . Jul 19, 2023 · We’re building the MEGAZORD of image generation power. A1111 prompt style (weight normalization) Lora tag inside your prompt without using lora loader nodes. 5 あたりで抑えることになるでしょう。 positive だけでなく negative についても同じように注意が必要 A1111 makes more sense to me. 00it/s with ComfyUI. 0 on my RTX 2060 laptop 6gb vram on both A1111 and ComfyUI the A1111 took forever to generate an image without refiner the UI was very laggy I did remove all the extensions but nothing really change so the image always stocked on 98% I don't know why. Mar 16, 2023 · No. Scenarios requiring custom workflows and integration of multiple models. 2) (best:1. I did try using SDXL 1. 0 Speed Test to find out which AI platform performs the fastest: ComfyUi, Invoke ai, or Automatic1111. So from that aspect, they'll never give the same results unless you set A1111 to use the CPU for the seed. 📌 Links: Furthermore, ComfyUI comes built in with several very useful capabilities including but not limited to: Paste this photo for a full workflow using stable diffusion XL and the refiner model. Apr 21, 2025 · The best ComfyUI alternatives are A1111 Stable Diffusion WEB UI, InvokeAI and FLORA. IP-Adapter + ControlNet (ComfyUI): This method uses CLIP-Vision to encode the existing image in conjunction with IP-Adapter to guide generation of new content. 그게 비해서 ComfyUI는 프롬 인식율을 상당히 높은데, 구현이 어려운 색상이나 모양은 a1111이 어떻게든 만들려고 하는건 있네요~ Stable Diffusion WebUI Forge is a platform on top of Stable Diffusion WebUI (based on Gradio) to make development easier, optimize resource management, speed up inference, and study experimental features. Notice the flip from s/it to it/s. Among other things this gives you the option to interpret the prompt weights the same way A1111 does things (something that seemed to be a popular request). ComfyUI also uses xformers by default, which is non-deterministic. In ComfyUI Desktop version, you can find extra_model_paths. AUTO1111 and ComfyUI unite with the sd-webui-comfyui extension from ModelSurge. Did they publish data on how much training costs? And did they publish the dataset? They had this to say about PIXART-alpha: As a result, PIXART-α's training speed markedly surpasses existing large-scale T2I models, e. A1111 breaks a lot and its so annoying to fix it. 1〜1. Feb 29, 2024 · A1111 Style Workflow for ComfyUI. Restart ComfyUI. A1111 has poor Better is subjective. [4] It uses Stable Diffusion as the base model for its image capabilities together with a large set of extensions and features to customize its output. Traditional UI. A1111는 기본적으로 GPU 노이즈를 생성합니다. Aug 10, 2024 · While ComfyUI and A1111 have their strengths, Forge emerged as the best choice for me. I don't know about the UI, in both A1111 and ComfyUI I always look the console. Only things I have changed are: SDXL 1. CUI can do a batch of 4 and stay within the 12 GB. What I would like to do is just simply replicate the Restart sampler from A1111 in ComfyUI (to start with). Forge 生成 A1111 と ComfyUI とを比較すると、同じ重みでも ComfyUI の方がかなり直接的で強く働くように感じられると思います。 ComfyUI では通常は 1. 8. 4) girl. Because of its strong momentum and pace of development, it’s likely also more future-proof. a1111는 전체적으로 프롬인식이 상당히 떨어집니다. May 4, 2024 · Use PAG on ComfyUI. 0 A1111 command line params: --opt-sdp-no-mem-attention --medvram Mar 22, 2024 · Forge, in particular, has the --forge-ref-a1111-home command which can reference the base directory of your Automatic1111 WebUI installation. Why is this? I saw mention that it's just a skin for ComfyUI? Does it somehow take advantage of Nvidias Tensorrt? Does my A1111 have wires crossed somewhere? Most importantly, does anyone else have massive speed differences with A1111 and The default way ComfyUI handles everything: comfy++: Uses ComfyUI's parser but encodes tokens the way stable-diffusion-webui does, allowing to take the mean as they do. I've been using A1111 for over a year now and I've never seen it flip to it/s. I love A1111, but there is a huge misconception somewhere in the app that author should look into. A1111: The default parser used in stable-diffusion-webui: full: Same as A1111 but whitespaces, newlines, and special characters are stripped: compel: Uses compel: fixed attention Dec 18, 2023 · a1111은 70스탭, cfg 29. Mar 22, 2023 · We made an extension for A1111 to embed comfyui in a tab. In simple terms, a model is a large dataset comprising a vast collection of training images We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Then i tested my previous loras with comfyui they sucked also. Oct 24, 2024 · The main difference between ComfyUI vs Automatic1111 is the level of customization and control. While the graph UI might Why? its very simple, A1111 is performing 7 iterations in one second, comfyUI is taking 1. And honestly, if nothing else, I’m glad to be done with using a Gradio interface! So, why ComfyUI是后来出的，为了避免浪费空间，ComfyUI支持使用Stable Diffusion WebUI 目录下的模型，而Stable Diffusion WebUI的作者名字是AUTOMATIC1111（简称A1111），有时候使用A1111称呼代替Stable Diffusion WebUI，这就是A1111替代的来源。 While kohya samples were very good comfyui tests were awful. Mar 21, 2024 · Inpainting with ComfyUI is a chore. I switched to ComyfUI from A1111 last year and haven't looked back, in fact I can't remember the last time I used A1111. But you can just look at the examples on their github. A good point you brought up is that A1111 only gets easier through video guides, and that's one of the biggest things ComfyUI is missing. Or download the PAG txt2img workflow below. Experimentation with cutting-edge features like SDXL and complex sampling methods. I think Invoke just lets you pick a model form any folder and doesn't force you to have models in any specific folder ( COuld be wrong, I haven't used this one very much and only vaguely remember pointing it at a few models to try out ). 02とA1111のv1. the other. A quality/performance comparison of the Fooocus image generation software vs Automatic1111 and ComfyUI. Select the corresponding menu item and open it with a text editor. For instance (word:1. A1111 is REALLY unstable compared to ComfyUI. This UI looks and feels like Automatic 1111, but has a lot of things already integrated. " The software takes care of the behind-the-scenes processing. 5 seconds to perform one iteration, therefore ComfyUI is slower. ~6,250 A100 GPU days), saving nearly $300,000 ($26,000 vs. I went from A1111 to ForgeUI and my speed just doubled (RTX 4080S) for image generation (ex: 512x512 Euler A 50 steps. invoke has a cleaner UI compared to A1111, and while thats superficial, when demonstrating or explaining concepts to others, A1111 can be daunting to the uninitiated. ; #Rename this to extra_model_paths. yaml. A1111 Stable Diffusion WEB UI is described as 'AUTOMATIC1111's Stable Diffusion web UI provides a powerful, web interface for Stable Diffusion featuring a one-click installer, advanced inpainting, outpainting and upscaling capabilities, built-in color sketching and much more' and is a ai image generator in the ai tools & services category. In ComfyUI I can see what each parameter applies to. ComfyUI nodes Visual Workflow vs. Looks like there's something cooking in the Dev branch, one can hope but I'm not that desperate as to try it. I found ComfyUI_restart_sampling custom node, but it's a bit more complicated. Why would the UI format change on different Chrome browsers? Could the recent 1. Nov 24, 2024 · 想问下用comfyu. “(Composition) will be different between comfyui and a1111 due to various reasons”. The Community Manual is incomplete and largely useless because it doesn't answer simple questions that any a1111 user Aug 29, 2023 · ComfyUI Model 位置設定. EasyLoader (A1111) Description Versatile node streamlining loading of AI art models and configurations for creative users. Do you use AUTOMATIC1111’s Stable Diffusion webui? Do you want to add the power of node-based AI workflows to the tools you already use? We’re committing STABLE INCEPTION today on Building Dreams. The easy a1111Loader is a versatile and user-friendly node designed to streamline the process of loading various models and configurations for AI art generation. yaml and ComfyUI will load it #config for a1111 ui # May 12, 2025 · How to Configure Model Sharing Between ComfyUI Desktop and A1111. I talk about A111 and ComfyUI I am completely new to this and wondering what the difference between A1111, controlNet, and comfyUI are? I know comfyUI and A1111 are GUIs but is there any significant difference between all three. #stablediffusionart #stablediffusion #stablediffusionai In this Video I have compared Automatic1111 and ComfyUI with different samplers and Different Steps. Funny thing is, when I load A1111 on a different Chrome browser, the format returns to normal. once you get comfy with comfy you don't want to go back. A1111 295MB vs Forge 126 MB. ComfyUI Desktop 版本安装教程; ComfyUI Desktop 版本现在原生支持英文、中文、俄语、日语、韩语; 有诸多体验优化 May 12, 2025 · 目前 ComfyUI 官方已推出 ComfyUI Desktop 版本，可以像普通软件程序一样安装，可以方便的进行安装，如果你是 Windows 用户，强烈建议你使用 ComfyUI Desktop 版本. ComfyUI has native support for the Perturbed Attention Guidance node. Advanced users who need granular control over the diffusion process. It is not implemented in ComfyUI though (afaik). A few weeks ago I did a "spring-cleaning" on my PC and completely wiped my Anaconda environments, packages, etc. In this video I go over the difference between Automatic1111 and ComfyUI and which one is better to use for stable diffusionSupport the channel on Patreon:pa I on the other hand realized the need for an actively maintained webui. Jan 14, 2025 · When to Choose ComfyUI. The weights are also interpreted differently. I've moved from A1111 to ComfyUI, but one thing I'm really missing is the Restart sampler found in A1111. But I don't know how does A1111 webui split things into tiles and upscale/denoise them. example file: For some reason a1111 started to perform much better with sdxl today. Can't wait until the A1111 comfyui extension is able to include txt2img and img2img as nodes via api. With Ksampler inspire you get the same result as with A111 with ComfyUI. Does comfyui working similar way and giving me boost against a1111? A1111 is known to run slower than ComfyUI and was prone to crash occasionally, though things are improving over time. ComfyUI is more user-friendly and suited for beginners, offering limited customization options, whereas Automatic1111 provides advanced users with extensive control and flexibility over image generation settings. everything ai is changing left and right, so a flexible approach is the best imho. In ComfyUI the prompt strengths are also more sensitive because they are not normalized. Next (Vlad) a fork of A1111 Improved memory performance New features arrive earlier, and higher volume Compatible with A1111 extensions Tabs were renamed, breaking a link between A1111 training material, and this offering which I think was unnecessary. If you haven't used nodes in the past, it can certainly be a bit daunting when you first start ComfyUI and are greeted with a blank canvas. That means you can use every extension, setting from A1111 in comfy. For a full overview of all the advantageous features We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I probably won't. However, it is incredibly hideous from a usability standpoint. Mar 29, 2024 · 如何在 ComfyUI 中从 a1111 重现相同的图像？ 您无法以像素完美的方式重现相同的图像，您只能获得相似的图像。 这是因为ComfyUI 上的空潜像噪声是在CPU上生成的，而 a1111 UI 上的空潜像噪声是在GPU上生成的。这使得 ComfyUI 种子可以在不同的硬件配置上重现，但使 I am a big fan of both A1111 and ComfyUI. SD. I have a 4090 so speed isnt an issue As some others have said, A1111 and ComfyUI are both great to have. Most UIs are form-based—you type a prompt, adjust a few sliders, and hit "Generate. you can drag and drop png to json to get the config, however A1111 is much more intuitive. A very short example is that when doing (masterpiece:1. ComfyUI는 기본적으로 CPU 노이즈를 생성합니다. This can be a good indicator that A1111 is doing extra function calls, and having more events to trace. 2 程度、最大でも 1. Dec 14, 2023 · easy fullLoader and easy a1111Loader have added a new parameter a1111_prompt_style,that can reproduce the same image generated from stable-diffusion-webui on comfyui, but you need to install ComfyUI_smZNodes to use this feature in the current version; v1. You don't need to switch to one or the other. A1111 and Comfy you have to edit a text file and paste the path to the extra models folder. And don't forget embedding: prefix for embeddings. E. 1でのVRAM消費と生成速度について比較してみました。 まずは比較元の設定について A. I don't like having to build the nodes in comfyui, and I admit I didnt spend more than three weeks in it, but often times when trying to be creative i could never get the nodes to work together. i started with invokeai, but have mostly moved to A1111 because of the plugins as well as a lot of youtube video instructions specifically referencing features in A1111. ComfyUI, on the other hand, exposes every part of that process as a node. 2 B. 我是用forge，不知咋的我用comui高清放大2倍有时候会爆显存，用forge不会，还更快。而且我用同模型提示词a1111参数啥的一致的情况下comui出图的质量不如forge。 Man, you're damn right! I would never be able to do this in A1111; I would be stuck into A1111's predetermined flow order. Clip Skip, RNG and ENSD options. you define the complexity of what you build. to calls comparing to Forge. 1 C. Nov 12, 2023 · これは原則として使えない、と思う。 理由は簡単で、A1111向けに開発されていたから。 一部は移植されているかも。 A1111は標準機能であったExtentionの検索はでComfyUIではデフォルトでは搭載されていないので、ComfyUI Managerというのを入れないといけない。 Keep your models so you don't have to download them again. In ComfyUI you can see the seconds that took to execute the whole workflow in the console. reForge  その他の設定 Paperspace Free-A4000 SDXL(VAE入り) Loraなし 解像度 1024x1024 ステップ 20 サンプラー DPM++2M スケジューラー Auto 1．通常生成の比較 A. It would ask me for a number of steps, and a scheduler, but not tell me what they controlled. 將第5行至20行的 # 刪除。 再修改 a111 以下的 base_path 做你存放 SD WebUI 的位置。 然後重啟 ComfyUI; 在 ComfyUI 內就可以讀取 Automatic1111 SD WebUI 內的 Models 了！ Jan 10, 2024 · 다만 HyperVAE 가 A1111는 적용이 되고, ComfyUI는 없습니다. py for generating the required workflow block because it'd be extremely tedious to create the workflow manually. It's obvious that a VAE is used to encode and decode an image because I can see it in the flow. While ComfyUI has a steeper learning curve, more advanced users will be able to design powerful workflows, especially when leveraging the rich custom node ecosystem. Read the article I wrote about seeds and Ksampler. So it is also a personal choice at this point. ComfyUI is a node-based AI image generation interface which supports both base Stable Diffusion, SDXL and FLUX models. A1111 v1. Stable Diffusion UI guide - A1111, Fooocus, ComfyUI, Invoke, Kohya by Sebastian Kamph inside ThinkDiffusion ↓Getting started with Stable Diffusion by ThinkDi Apr 15, 2023 · With the latest update to ComfyUI it is now possible to use the AdvancedClipEncode node which gives you control over how you want prompt weights interpreted and normalized. After more testing, I had found that after 75 characters in the prompt which also the clip limit. Forge v1. 7 update have caused this? Hi guys quick question. 그림이 생산되는 KSampler 그룹. 0. If you watch a lot of Stable Diffusion videos like me, I’ve seen many YouTubers shifting from A1111 to ComfyUI as it supports a deeper set of customizations with custom nodes from the community. 9 and it was quite fast on my 8GB VRAM GPU (RTX 3070 Laptop). Only arguments I used in A1111 were --xformers. CUI is also faster. 10. 일단은 A1111에서는 유무에 따라 결과물에 영향은 없습니다. $320,000) and reducing 90% CO2 Dec 26, 2023 · Watch the SDXL 1. I had to reinstall it so many times and watch so many YT videos dedicated to A1111 issues. Our crowd-sourced lists contains more than 10 apps similar to ComfyUI for Windows, Linux, Mac, Web-based and more. In the root directory is the extra_model_paths. I started on A1111 and just recently got ComfyUI and now I pretty much only use A1111 to connect to SD from my phone. 1) in A1111. (and a small commission to support this site. Dec 23, 2024 · 数か月、基本プログラムの更新がなくすっかり影が薄くなった感のあるA1111ですが、私は、ただ一つの機能が存在するが故にいまだに使い続けています。 その一つとは以下の記事にて詳説していますが、SDS1. Jun 5, 2024 · Check out Think Diffusion for a fully managed A1111 and ComfyUI online service. A1111 almost as same as ComfyUI base only. Now, a world of possibilities has opened; next, I will try to use a segment to separate the face, upscale it, add a lora or detailer to fine-tune the face details, rescale to the image source size, and paste it back. Note: be sure to put the refiner model in the checkpoints directory in the ComfyUI folder. That's not a figure of speech. ) The difference is that ComfyUI uses CPU and A111 GPU to compute the seed (see pytorch reference) and ComfyUI also injects noise as a variation for the image after the first one of a batch. Quick Recap – Automatic1111 vs ComfyUI ComfyUI is a powerful and flexible UI for generating text-to-image art. With A1111, you can easily page through a batch of them. 1) in ComfyUI is much stronger than (word:1. A1111 vs ComfyUI doesn’t necessarily have to mean one vs. I have yet to find anything that I could do in A1111 that I can't do in ComfyUI including XYZ Plots. Click the Manager > Update ComfyUI. Prompt: a frightened 30 year old woman in a futuristic spacesuit runs through an alien jungle from a terrible huge ugly monster against the background of two moons Jul 6, 2024 · For anything I feel is missing or could be improved, I can either use a Comfy workflow or develop a Simple tab workflow. With Automatic1111, it does seem like there are more built in tools perhaps that are helping process the image that may not be on for ComfyUI? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Still on A1111, using custom workflows and mostly doing just initial creative renders with it then compositing in Photoshop. It is a node based system so you have to build your workflows. 5, ComfyUI는 30스탭에 cfg 19. Open the extra_model_paths. 8% of Stable Diffusion v1. , PIXART-α only takes 10. May 7, 2024 · A1111 has almost 5x aten. Apr 20, 2024 · In A1111, the Regional Prompter plug-in can perform these same functions. Dec 27, 2024 · While I’m a dedicated user of the Automatic1111 and ComfyUI, I still do use Fooocus quite regularly to this day, that’s how fun this software is. They offer 20% extra credits to our readers. Often referred to as Stable Diffusion Web UI, A1111 can become your go-to tool for its versatility and user-friendly design. With ComfyUI, all you get are some medium-sized thumbnails, and the only way to get a good look at them is to open each one in a separate tab. ComfyUI. Better for more serious users, the changes make sense ComfyUI My UI in A1111 is messed up. The big current advantage of ComfyUI over Automatic1111 is it appears to handle VRAM much better. 30s/it with A1111 (1 picture @ 768x512) but I'll regularly get 1. ComfyUI uses the CPU for seeding, A1111 uses the GPU. I read that Forge increses speed for my gpu by 70%. I clicked Reload UI multiple times but didn't work. After using Comfy, A1111 just feels so rigid and clunky. g. despite the complex look, it's actually very I agree that Forge is quite a bit faster than A1111 in certain aspects, for instance when upscaling an 1024² image two times on A1111, after it already reached 100% it still takes more than 10s doing something until the rendered image is displayed. Here is a basic workflow: All the same parts are there as in Automatic1111, but what changes here is that the user has to right-click on the Load Image node and Aug 11, 2024 · A1111 (Stable Diffusion Web UI) While ComfyUI provides granular control over every step of the creative process, it can be overwhelming for those who prefer a more streamlined approach. com/ModelSurge/sd-webui-comfyui ComfyUI vs Invoke AI Invoke is a powerful, secure, and easy-to-deploy generative AI platform for professional studios that provides a flexible workflow builder with multi-user sharing and permissions, a step-by-step custom AI model trainer, and creation tools to provide the highest level of creative control to teams. Trace file size is also different. Nov 9, 2023 · Results are pretty good, and this has been my favored method for the past months. ) ComfyUI: At the other end of the spectrum is the increasingly popular ComfyUI tool for image generation. Uncover the winner now! Sponsored by Trae - Enjoy coding with the most advanced models at Zero cost We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I still find A1111 to be better suited for working with just one image, though, while ComfyUI is for batches (especially complicated workflows). Unfortunately I dont have much space left on my computer, so I am wondering if I could install a version of automatic1111 that use the Loras and controlnet from ComfyUI. Creating something from sratch in ComfyUI takes time and brain power. If the situation with A1111 is as dire as you paint it, we need to be looking for alternatives ASAP. You can even overlap regions to ensure they blend together properly. It also seems like ComfyUI is way too intense on using heavier weights on (words:1. Color Correct: simple but very effective tool to improve resulting image quality. Asked reddit wtf is going on everyone blindly copy pasted the same thing over and over. Once you have A1111 running again, you can take a look at ComfyUI and have the two share models. Added easy positive - simple positive prompt text. May 12, 2025 · ComfyUI has now released a ComfyUI Desktop version that can be installed like a regular software program. But the momentum of A1111 is hard to beat, I don't think most people will jump ship until the lack of support starts causing issues en masse. Image based templating for easy sharing of ComfyUI workflows. ComfyUI is the main alternative to A1111. Features. Think of it like this: Traditional UIs = "Type, click, and wait. Also, while ComfyUI is very powerful and flexible, most of what I usually want to do seems a lot more convenient and straightforward in A1111 My A1111 stalls when I press generate for most SDXL models, but Fooocus pumps a 1024x1024 out in seconds. But it is not the final answer. kpjuy fwlxwy qpe nwnvk kuxr tbxv rvuvh nosb tpenjgg psebh